Walid Shoebat – What constitutes a terror expert?

Salon.com has come across evidence this week that Walid Shoebat has been paid $5,000 by the Department of Homeland Security to speak at a conference for South Dakota law enforcement.

Admittedly, on the grand scale of questionable decisions DHS has made, this is pretty small.  There’s no evidence to suggest that Mr Shoebat is being brought on as a permanent adviser, and it’s not as though he’s speaking to every law enforcement agency in the country.

Nevertheless, I think this story well-illustrates what is so problematic about how Islam is presented and how information about Islam is disseminated in the US.  Mr Shoebat claims to be a former member of the Palestinian Liberation Organization who converted to Christianity in the 1990s.  There has been a great deal of speculation online as to whether his claimed biography is true – in particular, whether he ever bombed a bank in Bethlehem.  Obviously these questions are important as, I presume, Mr Shoebat’s experiences in the PLO are the reason why he was invited to speak by the DHS.

However, I would argue that even if his biography is entirely true, his status as an “expert” on Islamic terrorism is still unjustified.  I can certainly see the advantage in interviewing and speaking with former members of the PLO, as one particular kind of Middle Eastern extremist movement, but to equate all Middle Eastern, Arab and Islamic extremist movements seems, to me, to be a terrible oversimplification.  To presume that Mr Shoebat’s experiences are necessarily particularly representative of extremist movements, or that his experiences would make him knowledge about how these movements function on a larger scale, also seem like deeply problematic assumptions.

I have said before that part of what is frustrating, as an Islamicist, about reading what gets written in the media and online about Islam is that the standards for what constitutes an expert are so low.  For myself, I think of an “expert” as someone who has a wide range of tested knowledge on a subject.  Eye-witness accounts and personal experience are important, as these things make up the basis for sociological study.  But sociology is the categorization, analysis and study of personal experience  and eye-witness accounts.  If we mistake personal experience for wide-ranging expertise, we risk confusing anecdotal evidence for tested hypothesis and theory.  Without a larger analysis of how experiences like those of Mr Shoebat fit into a social and cultural setting, we lack the necessary material for properly understanding his experiences, or for answering the pressing questions of how and why do people join extremist movements, and how and why do these movements get exported around the world.  Mr Shoebat’s experience may be legitimate starting place for these conversations, but they cannot be sufficient in and of themselves.

About askanislamicist

I'm an academic who specializes in early Islamic history and the history of religious interactions, who, in her free time, enjoys shouting into the internet.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Walid Shoebat – What constitutes a terror expert?

  1. Uzza says:

    Mr Shoebat claims to be a former member of the Palestinian Liberation Organization, who converted to Christianity in the 1990s.
    Should that comma be there? I hadn’t heard of the PLO’s conversion.

    As for the OP, in the US an “expert” is a person who shares your ideology. They changed the definition in 2004.

    • Well spotted – corrected now! 🙂

      Aw, see I was already abroad then. Damn, I knew I shouldn’t have left. They haven’t changed the meaning of ‘pancakes’, have they? Because I really miss American pancakes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s